Ceramic, tantalum, and electrolytic capacitor comparison

Posted on Tuesday, December 20th, 2011 in parts by DP

Arhi made use of his precision LCR meter to measure capacitance and ESR values of ceramic, tantalum, and electrolytic capacitors. He made his measurements at various frequencies to help him graph the changes to the values over a wide frequency range.

From the graph it can be extrapolated that the ceramic capacitors have the lowest ESR values at any frequency up to the measured 100KHz. While the tantalum capacitors seem to be the most stable of the group.

Via the forum.

This entry was posted on Tuesday, December 20th, 2011 at 12:00 am and is filed under parts. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

3 Responses to “Ceramic, tantalum, and electrolytic capacitor comparison”

  1. arhi says:

    Note that 10uF is not your typical ceramic capacitor :D … I’ll do the same thing with 100n in next few days (100n is kinda the most used ceramic cap in digital electronic)

  2. rsdio says:

    I came across an article comparing ceramic, tantalum, and aluminum electrolytic caps – primarily focused on USB applications. Unfortunately, I lost the URL and misplaced the PDF. If anyone has seen such an article (the authors anointed aluminum electrolytic caps FTW), please let me know.

    • arhi says:

      aluminium ones are best on the usb as they have highest esr of all.. you know you have to limit the current on the usb and if you have a large ceramic the inrush will be too high and it will break usb standard…

Leave a Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Recent Comments

  • KH: TPS62200 will get him to under 15uA, a bit better than the 20-30uA he mentioned. I would try the same thing. Switch some resistors in...
  • KH: Yeah, it's an end-user thing. Very few people would spend hundreds of hours on this kind of project and sustain it. It's more or less...
  • Max: Not quite a dinosaur if you've seen Big Hero 6 though... wait. You've watched it with your kids, didn't you? That's cheating...! ;) One of...
  • Edward Mallon: A visiting researcher dropped by our humble basement workshop with questions about the physical skill level students would need if they added one of our...
  • KH: And that looks really expensive... Only browsed the vid though, I'm an dinosaur so I had the sound off too. Nice of him to open-source...