Choosing a substitute electronic part

Posted on Saturday, March 13th, 2010 in parts, skills by Ian

Choosing substitute electronic components is a common snag for beginners. What do you do if you can’t get the exact part used in a project? Part finder posed this question about the USB IR Toy:

This component is hard to find from my local store: D1, Small signal diode (DO323, BAS16HT1G, Rectifier 85V/0.2A Small Signal Diode).

Can I replace it for example with [this]?

What are the important values?

We didn’t give a particularly helpful reply, but Brian Willoughby picked up the slack with this fantastic description of how to pick a substitute part:

The most important value is the DO323, a.k.a. SOD-323. As Ian says, you can’t easily squeeze a different shape onto the PCB.

What I always do is hit Mouser. Start with a search for BAS16HT1G, and when you click on the Mouser part #, you’ll be given the opportunity to search for similar replacements. In this case, Mouser uses SOD-323 as the package / case. You can basically turn off the checkbox for everything else, because you don’t care about brand or other overly specific values. In the results that appear after clicking “Show Similar,” I tend to sort by price and then start narrowing down the options. Mouser finds about 425 options that would fit the PCB.

The actual selection process can be a little tricky. I recommend keeping a browser window open on the original part, and then use it as a guide to narrow things down in the search results. For example, after selecting general purpose diodes in the search results, I see recovery times of 4 ns, 6 ns, and 50 ns. Since the original part is 6 ns, I just select 4 ns and 6 ns to weed out the slower 50 ns diodes, just in case speed is important. Meanwhile, the lowest voltage is 70V and the smallest current is 150mA, so probably anything will do. If you’re concerned, then start specifying more values to narrow the results.

You’ll note that there is a 1N4148 in SOD-323 as part of the results.

If you want to speed up the process, the Mouser part # page for the original part will update the number of similar parts Found as you check or uncheck different specifications, so you can quickly experiment with how precise you want the match.

Great description of a tricky process, thanks Brian!

CC-BY-SA image by sparr0.

This entry was posted on Saturday, March 13th, 2010 at 8:55 am and is filed under parts, skills. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

4 Responses to “Choosing a substitute electronic part”

  1. masood says:

    gt20d201 substitute

  2. elia konzo says:

    FQPF 8N60CT semi conductor subsrute partsubtitute pleaseee

  3. dinesh says:

    BUK 455 sustitute

  4. Kevork says:

    HI, how and where one can search a substitute component . For example , I need the substitute part for93LC46 eight pin . Please, what part you suggest to replace the mentioned component? Can you e-mail me the necessary part number with some pin out explanation? Thank you in advance. .

Leave a Reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Recent Comments

  • Joe Desbonnet: Ya, I can recommend the low melting point solder. I used brand 'ChipQuik' and it's amazingly easy to use.
  • Jerome: I need a new BusPirate for the Fablab ;) Many thanks!
  • Max: Seems like an unexpectedly violent way to remove the chip indeed. A hot air station should of course do the job just fine, but in...
  • jose: Part removal described here is pure butchery, the cheapest hot air station will do a fast and clean job removing the QFP, heat air to...
  • Cody: Yes please